A.N.U.S.

American Nihilist Underground Society

ANUS.COM: American Nihilist Underground Society (A.N.U.S.) at www.anus.com
RSS feed of ANUS.com opinions and news Mailing list:
Search anus.com:

Nihilism, Futurist Traditionalism and Conservationism

Free will or free bird?

20 12 10 - 13:09


What has been long established is that "deterministic behaviour" - the idea that an animal poked in just such a way will react with the same response every time - is not a complete description of behaviour.

"Even the simple animals are not the predictable automatons that they are often portrayed to be," Dr Brembs told BBC News.

However, the absence of determinism does not suggest completely random behaviour either.

Experiments including Dr Brembs' own 2007 work with flies has shown that although animal behaviour can be unpredictable, responses do seem to come from a fixed list of options.

"Free will is not that lofty metaphysical thing that it was until the 1970s or so," Dr Brembs said.

"More and more people are realising that it's a biological property, a trait; the brain possesses the freedom to generate behaviours and options on its own." - BBC


Much of this is simply adaptive: there are very few rational options, so you pick one based on a number of factors.

I don't think "free will" makes much sense anyway as a term. Do they mean choice? Choice without reactivity? Certainly that's possible; video game AIs do it all the time. It's a calculation.

three comments

Kevbo
Here's an interview my "free will" (ethics) professor did with Galen Strawson about the unlikelihood of ultimate (moral) responsibility.

http://www.believermag.com/issues/200303/?read=interview_strawson Kevbo - 20-12-’10 13:51
awesome
great article. also, it follows that if " the brain possesses the freedom to generate behaviours and options on its own", then, of course, the most intelligent of us have more options ;) awesome - 21-12-’10 02:15
wow gold
Ive read a few excellent stuff here. Definitely price bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how a lot effort you place to create this type of fantastic informative site. wow gold http://www.iystwowgold.com wow gold (URL) - 29-01-’13 01:47


(optional field)
(optional field)

Remember personal info?
Small print: All html tags except <b> and <i> will be removed from your comment. You can make links by just typing the url or mail-address.