Black Metal, Death Metal, Grindcore, Thrash and Heavy Metal Reviews from the net's original Heavy Metal site

Metal Genres

Death Metal Black Metal Grindcore Thrash Speed Metal Heavy Metal

Metal Music

Heavy Metal MP3s Heavy Metal F.A.Q. Philosophy of Metal Interviews Metal Concerts Heavy Metal CDs

Metal Media

Opinions Heavy Metal Zines Heavy Metal Video Heavy Metal Books Metal Links

Metal Community

100% Metal Forum Letters to the Editor Our Writers E-mail List Metal Politics Metal Wiki Heidenlarm

Metal Blog :: Death to All Hype

« Eugenics Reviews | Eugenics Reviews III »

16 07 08 - 18:05 People Can't Tell Surface From Essence

So as I travel the internet on random errands, I hear people talking about the new "underground" bands, which all sound like Blink 182 making atmospheric black metal. It's pretty sad, but these bands insist they're not retro while tossing together bits and pieces of the past, wrapping them around standard pop-punk, adding some emo and crust and a pinch of necro, and then thrusting it all forward with that bedroom blackmetal "truly too authentic to care" aesthetic. I've listened to well over a hundred such bands in the last week, and on every level -- musically, aesthetically, artistically -- they're close enough to identical. Even more, they have nothing of distinction about them, so why bother? "Metal for metal's sake" is a path to mediocrity.

Then there are people who love to bloviate on about the "undiscovered" past gems, which almost universally are third-stringers with no distinction. Their goal is to make you think they know something you don't. They think they get ahead in life by pushing others down, and not simply by achieving more, because the two aren't the same, even in a relative universe. One of these so-called gems is Fester - Winter of Sin, which I threw on a week ago and had to laugh at how consistent judgment can be. For a smart person, whether in 1995 or in 2008, this CD is crap.

It starts with heavy metal riffs done up like black metal, and gets worse from there. It's a salad of pieces from here and there with no real direction except vague Venom worship. Every bad cliche of heavy metal and death metal is in here, and there's no melody or structure to recommend it. What does it have going for it? To weak people, it seems like a good way to be important, knowing about this undiscovered masterpiece etc. Avoid.

« Eugenics Reviews | Eugenics Reviews III »


one comment

I’ve had Winter of Sin For years, and remember liking it a bit at the time I got it, but now I mostly remember only perking up for the minute the violin showed up. I spun it after reading this, and you’re absolutely right. It reminds me now of similar vintage Cancer, who were probably the most generic death metal band of the era. What can I say? I was 14.
Laeth/Satan Is My Stewardess () - 18 07 08 - 03:16


  
Remember personal info?

/ Textile


 

  (Register your username / Log in)

Notify:
Hide email:

Small print: All html tags except <b> and <i> will be removed from your comment. You can make links by just typing the url or mail-address.
Death Metal and Black Metal Search Engine
Abigor Abomination Abruptum Absu Absurd Abyss, the Acerbus Agathocles Adramelech Adversary Amebix Amorphis Anarchus Ancient Ancient Rites Angelcorpse Antaeus Arcturus Asgard Asphyx Atheist Atrocity At the Gates Autopsy Auzhia Averse Sefira Baphomet Bathory Behemoth Beherit Belial Betrayer Blasphemy Blasphereion Blood Bolt Thrower Brutal Truth Burzum Cadaver Candlemass Capharnaum Carcass Carnage Cartilage Cathedral Celtic Frost Cenotaph Ceremonium Ceremony Cianide Corrosion of Conformity Cryptic Slaughter Cryptopsy Cultus Sanguine Dark Funeral Darkthrone Dark Tranquility Dawn Dead Brain Cells (DBC) dead horse Death Death Strike Deceased Deeds of Flesh Deicide Demigod Demilich Demoncy Deteriorate Dimmu Borgir Dirty Rotten Imbeciles (DRI) Disfear Disharmonic Orchestra Dismember Dissection Divine Eve the Doors Drogheda Emperor Engrave Enslaved Entombed Eucharist Exhumed Fallen Christ Fearless Iranians From Hell Fleshcrawl Frozen Shadows Gehenna Godflesh God Macabre Gorgoroth Gorguts Graveland Grotesque Gutted Havohej Hellhammer Hemdale Hetsheads Hypocrisy Ildjarn Immolation Immortal Impaled Nazarene Imprecation Incantation Infester Infernum Inquisition I Shalt Become Intestine Baalism Kataklysm Katatonia Kilcrops Killing Joke Kong Korrozia Metalla Kreator Krieg Kvist Lepra Lord Wind Luciferion Magus Malediction Manes Marduk Massacra Massacre Master Mayhem Merciless Molested Monastery Monstrosity Morbid Angel Morpheus Descends Mortem Motorhead Mortiis Mortuary Mysticum My Bloody Valentine Mythic Mütiilation Napalm Death Necromantia Necromass Necrophiliac Necrophobic Niden Div 187 NME Nox Intempesta Nuclear Assault Nuclear Death Num Skull Obituary Oppressor Ophthalamia Organic Infest Pathologist Pentagram Pestilence Possessed Powermad Profanatica Prong Pyrexia Rachel Barton Stringendo Ras Algethi Repulsion Resurrection Resuscitator Revenant Rigor Mortis Rise Rotting Christ Sacramentum Sadistic Intent Saint Vitus Samael Sammath Sarcofago Sarcophagus Seance Sentenced Sepultura Septic Flesh Setherial Sinister Skepticism Slayer Sodom Sorcier des Glaces Sort Vokter Speckmann Project Suffer Suffocation Supuration Summoning Swordmaster Tartaros Terrorizer Thanatopsis Tha-norr Therion Thorns Throne of Ahaz Torchure Torturer Troll Ulver Unanimated Under The Pagan Moon Uncanny Ungod Unleashed Vader Varathron Veles Voivod Von Watain Witchfinder General Xibalba Yamatu Zyklon-B
DEATH METAL AND BLACK METAL MAILING LIST